SUSTAINABLE TOURISM · TOPIC 11 · CLASS PRESENTATION

Future Directions

Digitalisation · Smart Tourism
& Regenerative Tourism

From smarter systems to places that give back more than they take.

FAN JIAPENG
Presenter
QIAO YIRAN
Presenter
Budapest Metropolitan University · Class presentation, 2026
Speaker notes · 0:00–0:45 · 15-minute box

Opening (0:00-0:45). Introduce ourselves and the topic. Say the presentation has three moves: what is new, what the evidence shows, and what we should be sceptical about. Tell the class there will be a short quiz and a discussion, so they should be ready to participate. Total time box: 15 minutes. If several topics are presented on the same day the brief caps us at 10 minutes: cut slides 5, 9 and 14 and shorten the discussion to one question.

Illustrative city-at-night photograph with a four-question concept diagram: the urban digital layer.
FIG. 1 · THE URBAN DIGITAL LAYER · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
01 THE HOOKSETUP

Your phone already decided where you will eat tonight.

A recommendation, a rating, a "top 10" list — and a neighbourhood that was never asked.

01
Who benefits
Who benefits when a city becomes "smart"?
02
Can it regenerate?
Can an algorithm actually regenerate a place?
03
Wrong goal?
What if efficiency is simply the wrong goal?

Hold that thought. We return to all three at the end — and we want your answers, not ours.

Speaker notes

Hook (0:45-1:30). Do not answer the questions yet. Ask for a quick show of hands on question 1 to warm up the room. This is deliberate: the CooSpace brief asks us to generate a discussion and active participation counts for 50% of the grade.

Illustrative smartphone photograph with a diagram of four decision questions.
FIG. 2 · RECOMMENDATION INTERFACES · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
01 ROADMAPSETUP

Three shifts, one argument

What is genuinely new — and what we will test against real cases.

01

DIGITALISATION

The infrastructure layer. Data, AI and platforms become the medium through which tourism is organised.

data · AI · platforms
02

SMART TOURISM

The optimisation layer. Real-time sensing and routing promise to make destinations run more smoothly.

sensors · real-time · flows
03

REGENERATIVE

The purpose layer. The goal shifts from reducing harm to actively rebuilding a place's capacity.

community · capacity · net gain

OUR CLAIM. Tools are neutral — outcomes depend on who controls them and what they optimise for.

Speaker notes

Roadmap (1:30-2:15). Frame the three layers. Emphasise that we will not simply celebrate technology. State the thesis clearly — it is the thread running through all 17 slides.

Illustrative city skyline with a three-tier stacked-layer diagram: digitalisation, smart tourism, regenerative.
FIG. 3 · THREE ACCUMULATING LAYERS · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
01 THE PERSONAL QUESTIONSETUP

What does the topic mean for you?

The brief asks us directly — so here are two honest answers, not a textbook definition.

FAN JIAPENG IN MY WORDS

To me, "future directions" is really a question of steering. Technology gives us a much faster car; regenerative tourism asks where we should actually drive — and who gets to hold the wheel.

Steering, not speed.

QIAO YIRAN IN MY WORDS

For me it is the gap between a dashboard and a place. A smart city can count every visitor and still miss whether the neighbourhood is thriving. I want to know what we choose to measure.

Measurement is a choice.

TOGETHER. The future is not more technology — it is better questions asked of it.

Speaker notes

Personal question (2:15-3:00). This slide answers the CooSpace requirement "What does the topic mean for you?" explicitly. Each of us speaks to our own card — split the delivery, roughly 20 seconds each. Keep it personal and concrete.

Illustrative misty mountain valley at sunrise with a place-versus-data concept diagram.
FIG. 4 · PLACE, NOT JUST DATA · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
01 FRAMINGSETUP

From doing less harm to leaving it better

Three waves of thinking — each one adds a layer, none replaces the previous one.

90s

SUSTAINABLE

1990s →
The question it asks: How much can we take?
Minimise damage · footprint · carrying capacity

10s

SMART

2010s →
The question it asks: How fast can we move?
Optimise flows · data · real-time decisions

20s

REGENERATIVE

2020s →
The question it asks: What can we give back?
Restore capacity · community · net positive

Crucially, a regenerative destination still needs the sustainability floor and the smart data layer underneath it.

Speaker notes

Framing (3:00-3:45). Explain the chronology briefly. The key point is layering, not replacement — this matters later when we argue that smart tools alone are not regenerative. Ask rhetorically which wave most destinations are actually operating in.

Academic line diagram of three accumulating waves labelled sustainable, smart and regenerative.
FIG. 5 · THREE ACCUMULATING WAVES · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
02 NOVELTY 01 · DIGITALISATIONWHAT'S NEW

The UN has put AI at the centre of tourism's agenda

"Digital Agenda and Artificial Intelligence to Redesign Tourism"

UN World Tourism Day 2026 · Official theme

Redesign, not just digitise

The wording moves from scanning tickets to re-writing how value and visibility are distributed.

AI as an allocator

Recommendation systems increasingly decide which places — and which platforms — receive demand.

A warning in the same breath

"Yet left unchecked, it can funnel tourists to the same few places and platforms…" — A. Guterres. The newest official framing already contains its own critique.

Source: UN Tourism, World Tourism Day 2026 official theme; message of the UN Secretary-General.

Speaker notes

Novelty 1 (3:45-4:45). This is the newest official issue: the 2026 World Tourism Day theme. Read the theme aloud. The Secretary-General's warning is important — we return to it as our bad example on slide 11. Do not present AI as neutral infrastructure.

Illustrative robot photograph with a diagram placing 2026, AI and regeneration at the centre.
FIG. 6 · AI AT THE CENTRE OF THE AGENDA · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
02 NOVELTY 02 · SMART TOURISMWHAT'S NEW

Hangzhou shows what "smart" looks like at city scale

APEC Smart Tourism Seminar, Hangzhou, 28–30 October 2026 · theme: "AI-era tourism services"

30s
hotel check-in
20s
park entry
100k
peak daily uses of the "Hang Xiaoyi" AI assistant
3M+
cumulative uses of the "Hi Tour" platform
40k+
service points mapped across the city
60%+
improvement in clearance / processing efficiency
Impressive — but every one of these measures speed and volume. None measures whether the destination is healthier.

Source: figures reported around the APEC Smart Tourism Seminar / Hangzhou municipal smart-tourism reporting, Oct 2026.

Speaker notes

Novelty 2 (4:45-5:45). Give the numbers quickly, do not read every one. The punchline is the amber bar: these are throughput metrics. Ask the room what a "healthier destination" metric would even look like — this seeds slide 13 on measurement. Note that these figures are as reported around the APEC seminar; be transparent about the source rather than over-claiming.

Illustrative Great Wall of China photograph with a six-metric data panel: 30s, 20s, 100k, 3M+, 40k+, 60+.
FIG. 7 · HANGZHOU AT CITY SCALE · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
02 NOVELTY 03 · REGENERATIVE TOURISMWHAT'S NEW

Regeneration changes the unit of success

The same destination, judged by a different question.

SUSTAINABLEREGENERATIVE
Reduce negative impactCreate net positive capacity
Carrying capacity as a ceilingCapacity as something to rebuild
Visitors as consumersVisitors as temporary stewards
Measure the footprintMeasure ecological and social return
Destination managed for touristsDestination shaped with residents
"Do less harm""Leave it better"

Working definition: tourism that leaves a place with more ecological, cultural and economic capacity than it had before.

Speaker notes

Novelty 3 (5:45-6:30). Walk down two or three rows only. The important conceptual move is from a ceiling (how much can we take) to a balance sheet (did we give back more than we took). Flag that "net positive" is hard to prove — that becomes the critical lens on slide 12.

Academic line chart rising from
FIG. 8 · FROM LESS HARM TO NET POSITIVE · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
03 CASE STUDY 01 · GOOD EXAMPLEEVIDENCE

Hangzhou: using data to disperse, not just accelerate

The mechanism · one chain, four links

01
Real-time data
Flows sensed across 40,000+ mapped service points
→
02
AI-assisted dispatch
The "Hang Xiaoyi" assistant answers and redirects
→
03
Visitor redistribution
Demand is steered away from the busiest hotspots
→
04
Lower pressure
Shorter queues and less crowding at pinch points

Why it works

Efficiency is a means, not the KPI

A 30-second check-in frees staff for service, not merely throughput.

Destination scale, not single-site

City-wide mapping lets flows be spread across many places at once.

Coordination in shared hands

A city-level platform can steer demand across sites, not only inside one attraction.

Still open: faster entry can also mean more total visits. Efficiency ≠ sustainability.

Source: APEC Smart Tourism Seminar, Hangzhou, Oct 2026; Hangzhou smart-tourism reporting.

Speaker notes

Good example 1 (6:30-7:30). This is our first of three main examples. Present the mechanism as a chain, then the three reasons. Importantly, end on the amber caveat — we are not uncritical fans. This shows the critical thinking the brief asks for.

Academic scatter diagram showing flows moving from concentrated to dispersed, with a four-step chain.
FIG. 9 · DISPERSING VISITOR FLOWS · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
03 CASE STUDY 02 · GOOD EXAMPLEEVIDENCE

New Zealand: Tiaki Promise and kaitiakitanga

THE PLEDGE · Tiaki Promise

1. Care for land, sea and nature, treading lightly and leaving no trace.
2. Travel safely, showing care and consideration for all.
3. Respect culture, travelling with an open heart and mind.

THE IDEA · kaitiakitanga

Tiaki means to care for people, place and culture. Kaitiakitanga is the Māori practice of guardianship — protecting a place for future generations, not consuming it.

A national pledge asking every visitor to care for land, sea and culture — and to travel safely and respectfully.

WHY THIS IS REGENERATIVE: it asks every visitor to act as a guardian — a role, not a transaction.

Source: Tiaki Promise (tiakinewzealand.com); concept of kaitiakitanga, Māori guardianship.

Speaker notes

Good example 2 (7:30-8:20). Contrast deliberately with Hangzhou: this example has almost no technology in it, yet it is more clearly regenerative. That contrast is the point. Pronounce kaitiakitanga carefully; explain it respectfully as a Māori concept of guardianship. The three pledges on the right are quoted verbatim from tiakinewzealand.com — read them as written.

Illustrative alpine lake photograph with a guardianship / care concept diagram.
FIG. 10 · GUARDIANSHIP OF PLACE · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
03 CASE STUDY 03 · BAD EXAMPLEEVIDENCE

When "smart" funnels everyone to the same few places

"Yet left unchecked, it can funnel tourists to the same few places and platforms, leaving many worthwhile destinations behind."

— António Guterres, UN Secretary-General, World Tourism Day 2026 message
PLACES
AI ranking
Hotspots degrade while nearby communities see almost no benefit.
→
PLATFORMS
Same "top 10" lists
Visibility becomes a paid asset; commission rates decide who survives.
→
TRAVELLERS
Overtourism + rent extraction
Choice narrows while the interface makes it feel personalised.
→
RESULT
Local capacity declines
The metric problem: the algorithm optimises engagement, not carrying capacity.

Source: António Guterres, UN Secretary-General, World Tourism Day 2026 message; UN Tourism.

Speaker notes

Bad example (8:20-9:20). This is our third main example and the direct counterweight to slide 6. Use the chain left to right. Point out that the failure is not a bug — it is what happens when the objective function is engagement. Ask who in the room has been sent to the same "hidden gem" as everyone else.

Illustrative Venice canal photograph with a funnel diagram from many places to few winners.
FIG. 11 · CONCENTRATION ON A FEW PLACES · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
04 CRITICAL LENSTHINKING

"Regenerative" is a label, not yet a method

GSTC's caution

buzzword · ambiguity · lacks a coherent operational framework

Without a definition and measurable criteria, the word can be attached to almost any product — including ones that change nothing.

Three red flags

1 · No baseline — nothing was measured before the claim was made.
2 · No community voice — regeneration decided in a brochure, not with residents.
3 · No net-gain evidence — only offset-style gestures, with no audited outcome.

If everything is regenerative, is anything?

Source: GSTC (Global Sustainable Tourism Council) commentary on regenerative tourism.

Speaker notes

Critical lens (9:20-10:10). This is where we are most sceptical of our own topic. GSTC's caution is a legitimate academic critique — cite it as such. The closing question is deliberately uncomfortable: we are students presenting on "regenerative tourism" and we should admit the term is not yet operationally settled.

Illustrative forest photograph with three red-flag markers for an undefined label.
FIG. 12 · A LABEL WITHOUT A METHOD · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
04 CRITICAL THINKINGTHINKING

Three questions to ask of every "future" claim

POWER

Who owns the data and sets the objective?

Who can switch the system off — and who cannot?

DISTRIBUTION

Who captures the value, who absorbs the cost?

Does the gain reach residents, or only intermediaries?

MEASUREMENT

What would count as proof of net gain?

Is there a baseline, an indicator and an audit?

Our working rule: a technology story without an answer to these three is a marketing story.

Speaker notes

Critical thinking (10:10-11:00). Offer this as a reusable checklist for the class, not just for our topic. Invite them to apply it to the Hangzhou case: power and distribution are largely unanswered there, measurement is a throughput metric only.

Academic triangle diagram linking power, distribution and measurement.
FIG. 13 · THREE QUESTIONS, ONE TEST · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
04 CHALLENGESTHINKING

Four things still standing in the way

The obstacles are institutional and political at least as much as they are technical.

01

DIGITAL DIVIDE

SMEs and rural destinations cannot afford the data infrastructure that "smart" quietly assumes.

02

PRIVACY & SURVEILLANCE

Real-time flows mean real-time tracking; consent rarely scales as fast as sensors do.

03

PLATFORM LOCK-IN

Once demand depends on a few intermediaries, destinations lose their bargaining power.

04

MEASURING REGENERATION

No agreed baseline, no agreed indicator, no comparable evidence across places.

The hardest is the fourth: you cannot manage what you cannot define.

Speaker notes

Challenges (11:00-11:50). These are the "challenges" the brief asks for. Keep it brisk — one sentence each. The fourth links back to the GSTC critique and forward to the discussion, so linger on it for a few seconds.

Illustrative city-at-night photograph with four obstacle markers: divide, privacy, lock-in, measurement.
FIG. 14 · INSTITUTIONAL OBSTACLES · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
05 INTERACTIVE · 60 SECONDSOVER TO YOU

Smart, regenerative, or neither?

Three short calls. Hands up, or shout it out — no wrong feelings, only interesting reasons.

01 · An AI system reroutes visitors away from a crowded square into quieter streets.
02 · A destination measures biodiversity before and after, and residents co-decide how tourism revenue is spent.
03 · A resort rebrands its existing "eco" package as "regenerative" on its website. Nothing else changes.

Select an answer to reveal our call. Answers stay hidden during the live talk — see the speaker notes.

We will take answers live before the discussion — and explain our own calls in the Q&A.

Speaker notes

Quiz (11:50-12:40). The brief explicitly suggests quizzes. Take answers by show of hands for each; ask one person to justify a choice. Our calls: Q1 = A (it optimises flows; no evidence of net gain). Q2 = B (baseline + community decision + measured outcome). Q3 = C (regenerative washing — see slide 12). Do not reveal the answers until the Q&A so the discussion stays open.

Illustrative laptop photograph with three quiz call-out strips.
FIG. 15 · MAKE A CALL · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
05 DISCUSSION · GENERATE A DISCUSSIONOVER TO YOU

Over to you

Pick one question, discuss in pairs for two minutes, then tell us what you decided.

01 · Should a destination be allowed to say "no" to an algorithm that sends it too many visitors?
Think about who has the legal and technical power to switch it off.
02 · If regenerative tourism needs a baseline, who should pay for measuring it?
Willing tourists, operators, or the public sector — and why?
03 · Would you trade a frictionless 30-second check-in for a slower trip that demonstrably benefits residents?
Back up your answer with a reason, not just a preference.

We will collect your answers and fold them into the Q&A — this is the part we most want from you.

Speaker notes

Discussion (12:40-14:00). This directly satisfies "Generate a discussion with your presentation!". Give the room two full minutes of pair discussion, then take 2-3 responses. Active participation is 50% of the course grade, so do not rush this. If the room is quiet, start with question 3 — it is the most personal and gets people talking.

Illustrative travel map and camera photograph with three discussion prompts.
FIG. 16 · DISCUSS IN PAIRS · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY
CLOSING · THANK YOU

Back to the phone

Your phone may still decide where you eat. The real question is who taught it to care about the place.

  1. Digitalisation is a tool, not a direction.
  2. Smart is about efficiency; regenerative is about purpose.
  3. If we cannot define and measure net gain, we cannot claim it.
Thank you — questions?
Fan Jiapeng · Qiao Yiran  |  Topic 11  |  Sustainable Tourism

Sources: UN Tourism, World Tourism Day 2026 · APEC Smart Tourism Seminar, Hangzhou, Oct 2026 · GSTC on regenerative tourism · Tiaki Promise, tiakinewzealand.com.

Speaker notes

Close and Q&A (14:00-15:00). Return explicitly to the three hook questions from slide 2 and answer them with the class's own discussion points. Reveal the quiz answers here. Then open the floor. Full references: UN Tourism World Tourism Day 2026 theme "Digital Agenda and Artificial Intelligence to Redesign Tourism" and the Secretary-General's message; APEC Smart Tourism Seminar, Hangzhou 28-30 October 2026, "AI-era tourism services"; GSTC commentary on regenerative tourism; Tiaki Promise, tiakinewzealand.com (kaitiakitanga).

Illustrative sunset over mountain ridges photograph with three closing points.
FIG. 17 · BACK TO THE PLACE · ILLUSTRATIVE PHOTO / CONCEPT DIAGRAM · NOT CASE-SITE IMAGERY